Dubnium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

The main dispute was about credit and the name. Berkeley and Dubna both claimed element 105 and gave it different names. In 1993 an international working group gave credit to both1, and in 1997 IUPAC named it in honor of the Dubna laboratory.

Dubnium is one of the superheavy elements. How they are made and who makes them →

Last updated 14 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

A team at Dubna, in the Soviet Union, reported element 105 in 1968. In 1993 the IUPAC-IUPAP Transfermium Working Group did not accept that evidence1. In 1970 Berkeley reported dubnium-260, and Dubna reported an isotope that splits by fission2. The Berkeley team could not confirm the Dubna results of 196821.

The working group judged the Berkeley paper of 1970 and a Dubna paper received in 1970 to be equally convincing. It gave credit to both laboratories1.

Each laboratory disagreed in part:

  • Albert Ghiorso and Glenn Seaborg, of Berkeley, wrote in 1992 that the Berkeley work clearly came first3. They called the Dubna fission work of that time inconclusive3.
  • Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara, of Dubna, wrote that the group underestimated some Dubna papers on element 105. They wrote that Dubna had agreed to cooperate with the working group3.

In 1993 the members of the working group examined the criticisms from Berkeley. They saw no reason to change their conclusions3.

Workers and communities

Only research staff in accelerator laboratories work with dubnium, one atom at a time. We found no report of an injury or illness from dubnium.

Who gains and who loses

We found no source on income from dubnium. The two proposed names, hahnium and nielsbohrium, were both in use until 19972. For a shared discovery, Dubna suggested in 1992 that the authors of both laboratories agree on names together3.

GSI, in Darmstadt, proposed nielsbohrium for element 107, together with Dubna3. GSI wrote that this would help to settle the dispute over element 1053. In 1994 an IUPAC commission accepted neither proposal and recommended joliotium for element 1052.

In 1997 IUPAC chose dubnium. It gave as its reason the role of the Dubna laboratory in methods for making heavy elements. It noted that other elements already honored Berkeley4. The commission hoped that its names would be accepted as a fair compromise4.

Sources

  1. 1

    IUPAC/IUPAP Transfermium Working Group (R. C. Barber, N. N. Greenwood, A. Z. Hrynkiewicz, Y. P. Jeannin, M. Lefort, M. Sakai, I. Ulehla, A. H. Wapstra and D. H. Wilkinson); Pure and Applied Chemistry 65(8), 1757-1814, 1993. Discovery of the transfermium elements , Part III, Element Z = 105, pp. 1783-1786.

    The working group's assessment of each Dubna, Berkeley and Oak Ridge paper on element 105, the name nielsbohrium, and the verdict that the credit is shared.

    • The reported evidence cannot be accepted as an indication for the existence of element 105.
    • The results mentioned in 105; 01 are discussed in this paper which reports that they cannot find any evidence for 9400 and 9700 keV lines.
    • Independent work reported in 1970 from Berkeley (70Gh02) and … from Dubna (71Dr01) was essentially contemporaneous and equally convincing. Credit for the … discovery should be shared.
    • Credit for the discovery should be shared.
  2. 2

    M. Thoennessen, National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory, Michigan State University (preprint for Atomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables), 2012. Discovery of Isotopes of Elements with Z ≥ 100 , arXiv:1203.2105v1, section 7, Discovery of 256-270 Db; section 6 for the 1994 name of element 104.

    The Berkeley and Dubna reports of 1970, the names hahnium, nielsbohrium and joliotium, and the discovery of each dubnium isotope up to 2010.

    • Dubnium was essentially discovered simultaneously in Berkeley reporting the discovery of 260 Db by Ghiorso et al. on April 17, 1970
    • Ghiorso et al. could not confirm earlier results by Flerov et al.
    • These names were in use until the controversy was resolved by IUPAC in 1997.
    • In 1994, the Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry of IUPAC had not accepted either of the suggestions and recommended joliotium instead
  3. 3

    A. Ghiorso and G. T. Seaborg (Berkeley), Yu. Ts. Oganessian and I. Zvara (Dubna), the GSI group, and the Transfermium Working Group; Pure and Applied Chemistry 65 (1993) 1815-1824, 1993. Responses on the report 'Discovery of the transfermium elements' , Section I (Berkeley, element Z = 105 and summary), section II (Dubna), section III (Darmstadt, element 107), section IV (TWG reply).

    Each laboratory's position on element 105 and its name, and the working group's reply. Read with Firecrawl; the quote cache holds an excerpt with the parts on element 105.

    • The definitive Berkeley work clearly preceded the Dubna work.
    • Earlier and contemporaneous work at Dubna based on their usual observation of decay by spontaneous fission was inconclusive
    • It seems to us that the TWG conclusions underestimate the importance of some Dubna papers on the elements 103, 104 and 105. But we have agreed to cooperate with the TWG
    • After detailed examination of all the criticisms from Berkeley we do not find it necessary in any way to change the conclusions of our report.
    • The best way out here could be a joint proposal of elements names formulated by the authors of priority papers.
    • This name was originally proposed by G. N. Flerov, JINR Dubna, for element 105.
    • we propose the name for element 107 together with our colleagues from JINR
    • This suggestion will also help to solve the controversy of naming element 105.
  4. 4

    IUPAC Commission on Nomenclature of Inorganic Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry 69(12), 2471-2473, 1997. Names and symbols of transfermium elements (IUPAC Recommendations 1997) , Recommendations, pp. 2472-2473, and the table of names and symbols.

    The reasons for the name dubnium and the approved name and symbol. The text in the quote cache is the full PDF, read in a browser for another element on the same day.

    • The Commission recommended that element 105 should be named dubnium in its honour.
    • The Berkeley laboratory has … already been similarly recognized on more than one occasion.
    • The Commission hopes that the present collection of names will be accepted as a fair compromise between the various claims and suggestions.