Chromium: social and political problems

What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?

Hexavalent chromium, a form made mostly in industry, causes lung cancer in workers who breathe it. Chromium waste has polluted water in California, India and Bangladesh. In South Africa, the government, miners and smelters disagree about a tax on ore exports.

Last updated 10 October 2026.

Conflict and disputes

In South Africa, the dispute is about where the ore is smelted. The government has proposed a tax on chrome ore exports. The miners and smelters reject it. South Africa was once the largest maker of ferrochromium, but it lost this place to China. Reuters reports that this was mostly because of high electricity costs1. The International Chromium Development Association links China’s rise to its growing stainless steel industry2.

The cabinet proposed the tax in 2020. The government said that it was part of a strategy to support the country’s ferrochromium industry3. In June 2025 the cabinet proposed the tax again, to stop the decline of the industry1.

The Minerals Council South Africa, which represents the largest miners, said that the tax would not keep the smelters open or save jobs1. In December 2025 chrome ore producers and ferrochromium smelters also rejected the tax. They said that only competitive electricity tariffs could restart the idle plants4.

In June 2026 a new industrial strategy again set the target of an export tax and quota. The Minerals Council said that the rise in electricity tariffs is the main reason why smelters closed, not the supply of ore55.

Workers and communities

Hexavalent chromium, or chromium(VI), is chromium in a form that is usually made by industrial processes6. Three agencies classify chromium(VI) compounds as known human carcinogens. They are the US Department of Health and Human Services, the International Agency for Research on Cancer and the US EPA. In workers, breathing them causes lung cancer7. OSHA names welding on stainless steel as a major source of exposure66.

Skin contact with some chromium(VI) compounds can cause skin ulcers. Some people are allergic to chromium(VI) or chromium(III). ATSDR says that in animals that swallowed them, chromium(III) compounds were much less toxic than chromium(VI)77. Since 2006 the US limit in workplace air is 5 micrograms per cubic meter, averaged over 8 hours8.

From 1952 to 1966, the gas company PG&E used chromium(VI) against corrosion in the cooling water of its compressor station near Hinkley, California. Waste water went into unlined ponds and polluted the groundwater9. The regional water board says that the polluted groundwater is at least eight miles long and two miles wide9.

In India, the Sukinda Valley in Odisha holds about 97% of the country’s chromite deposits, in open-cast mines. Mine waste along the valley affects the local water1010. The environmental group Pure Earth estimates that 2.6 million people are affected10.

In the tanneries of Hazaribagh, in Dhaka, Human Rights Watch found in 2012 that workers, including children as young as 11, became ill from chemicals11. In one tannery’s waste water, Human Rights Watch gives a chromium level of 4,043 mg per liter, against a standard of 2 mg per liter11.

Who gains and who loses

In South Africa, the Minerals Council says that the chrome sector directly employs 25,000 people. It says that the sector earned 85 billion rand ($4.85 billion) from exports in 20241.

Smelters have closed. In 2020 the newspaper BusinessLive reported that 40% of the country’s ferroalloy capacity had stopped in three years, mainly because of electricity prices3. Exports of ore to China grew. In 2024 South Africa exported a record 20.5 million tonnes of chrome concentrate, mostly to China1.

The producers also report illegal chrome mining. They estimate that it earns about 8 billion rand a year and gives about 10% of South Africa’s chrome ore exports4.

Public debate

In California, the limit for chromium(VI) in drinking water has been disputed. The State Water Board says that chromium(VI) is used in industry and also occurs naturally in the environment12. A state limit of 10 parts per billion took effect in 20149. In 2017 a court in Sacramento cancelled it. The court found that the state had not properly considered the economic feasibility of the limit. It made no finding on whether the limit protected health1212. A new limit of 10 micrograms per liter took effect on 1 October 202412.

Sources

  1. 1

    Reuters (republished by Republikein, 7 July 2025), 2025. South African miners say proposed chrome export tax threatens jobs .

    The 2025 export tax proposal, the Minerals Council's view, jobs and exports.

    • lost that pole position to China, mostly due to high electricity costs which have forced many smelters to shut
    • as part of efforts to stop the decline of the ferrochrome industry
    • would not achieve the government’s aims of sustaining the ferrochrome industry and the preservation of jobs
    • South Africa’s chrome sector directly employs 25,000 people and earned the country 85 billion rand ($4.85 billion) in export revenue in 2024, according to the Minerals Council
    • It exported a record 20.5 million metric tons of chrome concentrate in 2024, mostly to China
  2. 2

    International Chromium Development Association, 2026. Market insights .

    South Africa as the main producer, UG2, China as the main ferrochromium producer and ore importer, 2025 production.

    • In 2012, driven by its rising stainless steel industry, China became the biggest FeCr producer worldwide
  3. 3

    Miningmx (22 October 2020), 2020. SA to apply export tax on chrome exports in effort to support domestic ferrochrome .

    The 2020 cabinet proposal for an export tax, exports to China, electricity prices for smelters.

    • a development the government said was part of a strategy to support the country’s domestic ferrochrome industry
    • In the past three years, 40% of South Africa’s ferroalloy capacity has been idled because it is no longer competitive
  4. 4

    Miningmx (1 December 2025), 2025. Chrome industry rejects export tax proposal .

    The views of producers and the ferroalloy association on the export tax, electricity prices and illegal mining.

    • chrome ore producers and ferrochrome smelters have rejected proposals for a chrome ore export tax, arguing that globally competitive electricity tariffs represent the only viable solution to restarting idled facilities
    • illegal chrome mining, which generates an estimated R8bn annually and accounts for roughly 10% of South Africa’s chrome ore exports
  5. 5

    Miningmx (D. McKay, 9 June 2026), 2026. Chrome export levy resurfaces in new industrial strategy .

    The revised South African Industrial Development Strategy, the export tax and quota target, the Nersa tariff for ferrochromium producers, the Minerals Council's response.

    • Institute [an] export tax and quota for the chrome industry
    • The more than 900% increase in electricity tariffs since 2008 is the primary reason behind the closure of smelters
  6. 6

    US Occupational Safety and Health Administration, 2026. Chromium: Hexavalent Chromium .

    Health effects of hexavalent chromium and the main sources of worker exposure.

    • Hexavalent chromium [Cr(VI)] is one of the valence states (+6) of the element chromium. It is usually produced by an industrial process
    • A major source of worker exposure to Cr(VI) occurs during
    • such as welding on stainless steel and other alloy steels containing chromium metal
  7. 7

    Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (US CDC), 2026. ToxFAQs for Chromium .

    Cancer classification of hexavalent chromium compounds and exposure routes.

    • have determined that chromium(VI) compounds are known human carcinogens. In workers, inhalation of chromium(VI) has been shown to cause lung cancer
    • Chromium(III) compounds are much less toxic and do not appear to cause these problems
    • Skin contact with certain chromium(VI) compounds can cause skin ulcers. Some people are extremely sensitive tochromium(VI) or chromium(III)
  8. 8

    US Occupational Safety and Health Administration, 2026. 29 CFR 1910.1026, Chromium (VI) , 1910.1026(c) Permissible exposure limit; 1910.1026(n) Dates.

    The US workplace limit for hexavalent chromium in air and its start dates.

    • 5 micrograms per cubic meter of air … commence November 27, 2006
  9. 9

    California Regional Water Quality Control Board, Lahontan Region, 2026. PG&E Hinkley Chromium Cleanup .

    Use of hexavalent chromium at Hinkley from 1952 to 1966 and the size of the groundwater plume.

    • Between 1952 and 1966, PG&E used hexavalent chromium, also known as chromium 6, to fight corrosion in cooling tower water. The wastewater from the cooling towers was discharged to unlined ponds at the site
    • The chromium affects an area of groundwater at least eight miles long and two miles wide
    • On July 1, 2014, the hexavalent chromium Drinking Water Standard of 10 parts per billion came into effect
  10. 10

    Pure Earth, 2026. India – Sukinda Valley .

    Hexavalent chromium pollution from chromite mining in the Sukinda Valley, Odisha, and Pure Earth's estimate of the people affected.

    • about 97 percent of the nation’s deposits are found in the mineral-rich earth of the Sukinda Valley
    • Overburden and tailings are located all long the valley and impact the local water systems
    • Population affected 2,600,000
  11. 11

    Human Rights Watch, 2012. Toxic Tanneries: The Health Repercussions of Bangladesh's Hazaribagh Leather .

    Work and pollution in the leather tanneries of Hazaribagh, Dhaka.

    • including children as young as 11, become ill because of exposure to hazardous chemicals
    • chromium (4,043 mg/L, against a standard of 2 mg/L)
  12. 12

    California State Water Resources Control Board, Division of Drinking Water, 2026. Hexavalent Chromium MCL .

    California's limits for hexavalent chromium in drinking water, the 2017 court decision and the 2024 limit.

    • Hexavalent chromium is a heavy metal that has been used in industrial applications and found naturally occurring throughout the environment
    • failed to properly consider the economic feasibility of complying with the MCL
    • The court did not make any finding about whether the MCL adequately protected public health
    • State Water Board adopted the Hexavalent Chromium MCL Regulation with an effective date of October 1, 2024