Carbon: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
Rebel groups have used diamonds to pay for wars, and the Kimberley Process works against this. Coal mine accidents in China killed 6,995 people in 2002. Fossil carbon emissions are unequal. The Global Carbon Project says the 1.5 °C carbon budget is nearly used up.
Last updated 5 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
The Kimberley Process defines conflict diamonds as rough diamonds that rebel movements or their allies use to pay for wars against legitimate governments1. The Kimberley Process also helps to enforce UN Security Council sanctions on the trade in conflict diamonds. It names Liberia and Côte d’Ivoire as past examples1. Its certification scheme started in 20031.
The scheme has critics. In 2011, the campaign group Global Witness left the Kimberley Process. It said the scheme had failed on diamonds from Côte d’Ivoire, Venezuela and Zimbabwe2. Global Witness says the army of Zimbabwe took control of the Marange diamond fields in 2008 and killed about 200 miners2. Human Rights Watch reported in 2009 that the army killed at least 214 miners from October 27 to November 16, 20083. Zimbabwe’s minister of mines told parliament that the police had assured his ministry that the army and police had killed no one3.
In 2025, sanctions by the United States, the EU and the G7 on Russian diamonds stayed in effect. The USGS says the aim is to limit Russia’s ability to fund the war4.
Graphite is part of a trade dispute between the United States and China. In December 2024, North American graphite producers asked US agencies to review China’s trade practices for anode material. The USGS reports that the US International Trade Commission found the material likely to be sold below fair value5.
Workers and communities
In China, deaths in coal mines fell from 6,995 in 2002 to 375 in 2017, a fall of 94.6%6. The death rate fell from 5.07 per million tonnes of coal in 2001 to 0.044 in 20216. From 2017 to 2021 there were 790 coal mine accidents in China, with 1,433 deaths6.
At graphite mines, the main environmental concerns are fine dust and hydrocarbon vapors from mining and processing. Graphite itself is chemically inert and not toxic7.
In June 2026, Mozambique began to require that 10% of mining revenues go to local communities8. Production at the Balama graphite mine in Mozambique stopped in late 2024 and restarted in June 20255.
Who gains and who loses
Fossil carbon emissions are unequal between countries. In 2024, the world emitted 1.3 tonnes of fossil carbon per person. The figure was 3.9 tonnes in the United States, 2.4 in China, 1.5 in the EU and 0.6 in India9.
The totals since 1850 also differ. From 1850 to 2024, US emissions were 120 billion tonnes of carbon (24% of the world total). The EU’s were 80 billion tonnes (16%), China’s 80 billion (15%) and India’s 18 billion (4%)9.
Graphite production is growing in East Africa. Tanzania more than doubled its output in 2025, and new mines opened in Tanzania and Mozambique in 2024 and 20255.
Public debate
The Global Carbon Project publishes a yearly estimate of the remaining carbon budget. It says the remaining budget for a 50% chance to limit warming to 1.5 °C is nearly used up. It is about 50 billion tonnes of carbon, or about four years at 2025 emissions9. It puts human-caused warming at 1.36 °C in 20249.
The IEA’s scenarios give different results. Its Current Policies Scenario leads to almost 3 °C of warming by 2100, and its Stated Policies Scenario to about 2.5 °C10. In its Net Zero Emissions scenario, warming peaks around 2050 at about 1.65 °C10.
Sources
- 1
Kimberley Process, 2026. What is the Kimberley Process? .
Definition of conflict diamonds and the start of the certification scheme in 2003.
-
Conflict diamonds mean rough diamonds used by rebel movements or their allies to finance conflict aimed at undermining legitimate governments
-
relevant UN Security Council resolutions containing sanctions on the trade in conflict diamonds. Historic examples include Liberia and Côte d’Ivoire
-
Launched in 2003
-
- 2
Global Witness (press release, 2 December 2011), 2011. Global Witness leaves Kimberley Process, calls for diamond trade to be held accountable .
Why Global Witness left the Kimberley Process; the Marange diamond fields in Zimbabwe.
-
it failed to deal with the trade in conflict diamonds from Côte d’Ivoire, was unwilling to take serious action in the face of blatant breaches of the rules over a number of years by Venezuela and has proved unwilling to stop diamonds fuelling corruption and violence in Zimbabwe
-
The Zimbabwean army seized control of the area in 2008, killing around 200 miners
-
- 3
Human Rights Watch, 2009. Diamonds in the Rough: Human Rights Abuses in the Marange Diamond Fields of Zimbabwe , Section VI, Human Rights Abuses by the Zimbabwe Defence Forces (October 2008 to June 2009), and the government response.
Killings of miners at Marange in 2008, and the response of Zimbabwe's minister of mines.
-
over the period October 27 to November 16, 2008, the army killed at least 214 miners
-
the police had assured his ministry that the military and police had not killed anyone during the
-
- 4
U.S. Geological Survey, 2026. Gemstones, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , Events, Trends, and Issues; World Gem Diamond Mine Production and Reserves.
World gem diamond production by country, sanctions on Russian diamonds and the market downturn.
-
These sanctions prohibited the import of rough and finished gem-grade diamonds from Russia, including diamonds processed in third countries, to limit Russia’s ability to fund its conflict with Ukraine
-
- 5
U.S. Geological Survey (A.A. Stewart), 2026. Graphite (Natural), in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 , World Mine Production and Reserves; Events, Trends, and Issues; Recycling; Substitutes.
World natural graphite production and reserves, prices, trade and US duties.
-
a group of graphite producers based in North America submitted a petition
-
The ITC determined that AAM from China was likely being sold at less than fair market value in the United States
-
an Australian company restarted production at the Balama Mine in June after being suspended since late 2024
-
In 2025, Tanzania more than doubled graphite production to 75,000 tons
-
In Mozambique, a Chinese company began production at a new graphite mine in Niassa
-
- 6
Zhang et al., International Journal of Coal Science & Technology, 2023. Analysis of the development status of coal mine safety in China (Int J Coal Sci Technol 10:22) , Section on coal mine accidents, Fig. 4.
Deaths in Chinese coal mines from 2001 to 2021.
-
the death toll in coal mines dropped from 6995 in 2002 to 375 in 2017, with a decrease of 94.6%
-
from 5.07 in 2001 to 0.106 in 2017
-
decreased by 58% from 0.106 in 2017 to 0.044 in 2021
-
There were altogether 790 coal accidents with 1433 fatalities over the past five years (2017–2021)
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey (G.J. Robinson Jr., J.D. Hammarstrom, D.W. Olson), 2017. Graphite, chapter J of Critical Mineral Resources of the United States (Professional Paper 1802-J) , Abstract; Geology; Deposit Types.
How graphite deposits form, deposit types and grades, synthetic graphite.
-
Because graphite is chemically inert and nontoxic, the main environmental concerns associated with graphite mining are inhalation of fine-grained dusts, including silicate and sulfide mineral particles, and hydrocarbon vapors produced during the mining and processing of ore
-
- 8
International Energy Agency, 2026. Global Critical Minerals Outlook 2026 , Chapter 2, Graphite, p. 163-169; Table of export restrictions.
Graphite demand, supply, prices, export controls and tariffs in 2025 and 2026.
-
required 10% of mining revenues to be directed to local communities
-
- 9
Friedlingstein P. et al. (Global Carbon Project), Earth System Science Data 18, 3211-3288, 2026. Global Carbon Budget 2025 , Abstract; Executive summary; Sect. 3.1 Fossil CO2 emissions; Sect. 3.8 cumulative sources and sinks.
Fossil CO2 emissions in 2024 and 2025, by fuel and country, cumulative emissions, CO2 in the air, ocean and land sinks, remaining carbon budgets.
-
The per-capita fossil CO2 emissions in 2024 were 1.3 tC person−1 yr−1 for the globe, and were 3.9 (USA), 2.4 (China), 1.5 (EU27) and 0.6 (India)
-
US cumulative emissions amounted to 120 GtC (24 % of world total), the EU’s to 80 GtC (16 %), China’s to 80 GtC (15 %), and India’s to 18 GtC (4 %)
-
a 50 % likelihood to limit warming to 1.5 °C is nearly exhausted (50 GtC, 170 GtCO2 left, equivalent to around 4 years at the 2025 emissions levels)
-
consistent with the warming of the planet attributed to human activities, which reached 1.36 °C in 2024
-
- 10
International Energy Agency, 2025. World Energy Outlook 2025 , Executive summary; Overview; section 4.5 Fuels; Annex A, Table A.1b World energy supply and Table A.2b World total final consumption (Stated Policies, columns 2010, 2023, 2024); Annex C, definitions.
Fossil fuel share of energy demand, the IEA scenarios to 2050, and world supply and use of coal, oil and gas by sector in 2010, 2023 and 2024.
-
The emissions trajectory in the CPS is consistent with warming of almost 3 °C by 2100, whereas lower levels of emissions in the STEPS keep this to around 2.5 °C
-
Scenario, warming peaks around 2050 at about 1.65 °C
-