Cesium: social and political problems
What problems does it cause between people, and who carries them?
The main harm to people came from radioactive cesium-137. In 1987 in Goiânia, Brazil, an abandoned medical source killed four people. The Chernobyl accident spread it over large parts of Europe. The main dispute is between Canada and Sinomine, the Chinese owner of the Tanco mine.
Last updated 13 October 2026.
Conflict and disputes
We found no war or armed conflict about cesium. The main dispute is between the government of Canada and Sinomine.
In November 2022 Canada ordered Sinomine’s Hong Kong company to sell its stake in Power Metals, after a national security review1. The government said its decisions were based on facts and evidence and on the advice of its security and intelligence community1.
Sinomine disagreed in a letter to the ministry, reported by the Globe and Mail. It said that Canada had named the wrong company as its biggest shareholder, because of a poor translation2. Sinomine said that its biggest shareholder, Zhongse Mining Group, has no ties to the Chinese government2. It said that its decisions are made only for commercial reasons2. A spokesperson for the Canadian ministry told the newspaper that such reviews involve rigorous scrutiny, and that decisions are based on facts and evidence2.
Workers and communities
The USGS knows of no health problems from natural cesium3. Most harm came from radioactive cesium-137, made in nuclear reactors.
Goiânia, Brazil, 1987. A private radiotherapy clinic moved and left a cesium-137 source behind in its old building. Two people took the source home and broke it open4. A junkyard owner saw that the powder glowed blue in the dark. Friends and family came to see it, and small pieces went to several families4.
Four people died, and 28 had radiation burns. About 3,500 cubic meters of radioactive waste resulted4. The authorities checked some 112,000 people, and 249 of them were contaminated4. Seven houses were demolished4.
Chernobyl, 1986. The reactor accident put cesium-137 above 37 kBq per square meter on more than 200,000 square kilometers of Europe5. The IAEA wrote that cesium-137 in milk and meat stays the main source of internal dose in the long term5.
Fukushima, 2011. The accident at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power station in Japan released cesium-137 into the air. The UN Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR) estimates 6 to 20 petabecquerels6. It estimates this at about 20% of the cesium-137 that Chernobyl released6. UNSCEAR found no documented health effects among residents of Fukushima Prefecture that come directly from the radiation6.
Medical sources. In May 2019 a cesium-137 blood irradiator leaked while it was moved from a medical research center to a disposal site7. Stable cesium can also cause harm. Cesium chloride has been used as an alternative cancer treatment7. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) warned health care professionals about its risks in July 2018. In 2020 it warned consumers not to use supplements with cesium salts8. The FDA named the risks as heart rhythm problems that can kill, low potassium, seizures and fainting8.
Who gains and who loses
We found no study of who gains or loses from cesium mining. The mines are small. In 2004 the USGS wrote that mining and processing were on so small a scale that the harm to the environment was minimal9.
At Tanco, the Globe and Mail reported that Sinomine was thinking of draining part of the lake above the mine. A lawyer told the newspaper that this would probably need a federal impact assessment, because of the effects on fish2. We found no later report on a decision.
Public debate
The debate is about Chinese control of supply. Christopher Ecclestone is a mining strategist at the research firm Hallgarten + Co. In the Globe and Mail, he said that Canada and the United States should refuse a cesium expansion by Sinomine. He said the strategy should be to keep the cesium in the ground2.
Frank Wang, who leads Sinomine’s North American business, said the company has no connection to the Communist Party of China2. He asked for more dialogue with Canada2.
Sources
- 1
Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, 2022. Government of Canada orders the divestiture of investments by foreign companies in Canadian critical minerals companies .
The order of November 2022 that Sinomine sell its investment in Power Metals. Read with Firecrawl.
-
Sinomine (Hong Kong) Rare Metals Resources Co., Limited is required to divest itself of its investment in Power Metals Corp.
-
The government’s decisions are based on facts and evidence and on the advice of critical minerals subject matter experts, Canada’s security and intelligence community, and other government partners.
-
- 2
The Globe and Mail (Niall McGee), 2023. China’s Sinomine eyeing major expansion at Tanco mine in Manitoba to boost critical minerals production .
Sinomine's cesium mining and processing at Tanco, its plans for an open pit, and Canadian policy.
-
Sinomine said that Ottawa got it wrong in claiming that state-owned enterprise (SOE) firm China Nonferrous Metal Mining Group is Sinomine’s biggest shareholder.
-
ISED’s error, it seems, stemmed from a botched translation
-
The company said that its biggest shareholder is, in fact, Zhongse Mining Group, which has no ties to the Chinese government.
-
solely for commercial purposes
-
by Canada’s national security and intelligence community, and decisions are based on facts and evidence
-
The reason it would probably trigger a federal impact assessment would be because of the Fisheries Act
-
Mr. Ecclestone argues that the response from Canada and the United States should be an unequivocal no to a cesium expansion by Sinomine.
-
keep it in the ground
-
The company has no connection whatsoever to the Communist Party of China, he says.
-
We are willing to discuss all kinds of possibilities and opportunities in order to be able to work together.
-
- 3
U.S. Geological Survey (Candice C. Tuck), 2026. Cesium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 .
Uses, catalogue prices of 2024 and 2025, recycling, import reliance, production at Tanco and Bikita, projects, reserves, resources and substitutes.
-
No known human health issues are associated with exposure to naturally occurring cesium
-
- 4
International Atomic Energy Agency, 1988. The Radiological Accident in Goiânia .
The cesium-137 accident of 1987 in Goiânia, Brazil.
-
Two people entered the premises and, not knowing what the unit was but thinking it might have some scrap value, removed the source assembly from the radiation head of the machine.
-
He noticed that the source material glowed blue in the dark.
-
Fragments of the source the size of rice grains were distributed to several families.
-
Four of the casualties ultimately died and 28 people suffered radiation burns.
-
In total about 3500 m 3 of radioactive waste were generated.
-
112 000 persons were monitored, of whom 249 were contaminated
-
The work included the demolition (and removal) of seven houses and the removal of soil.
-
- 5
The Chernobyl Forum (IAEA and other UN agencies), 2006. Chernobyl's Legacy: Health, Environmental and Socio-Economic Impacts .
Cesium-137 from the Chernobyl accident in Europe, in soils and in food.
-
More than 200 000 square kilometres of Europe received levels of 137Cs above 37 kBq m-2.
-
In the long term 137Cs in milk and meat and, to a lesser extent, 137Cs in plant foods and crops remain the most important contributors to human internal dose.
-
- 6
United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation, 2022. UNSCEAR 2020/2021 Report, Volume II, Scientific Annex B: Levels and effects of radiation exposure due to the accident at the Fukushima Daiichi Nuclear Power Station , Paragraphs 36 and 244.
The release of cesium-137 to the air from the Fukushima Daiichi accident, compared with Chernobyl, and the health effects.
-
that of 137Cs was generally in the range of 6 to 20 PBq
-
the estimated releases (based on the averages of published estimates) of these radionuclides from the FDNPS accident were about 10% and 20% for 131I and 137Cs, respectively, of the releases of these radionuclides estimated for the Chernobyl accident
-
no adverse health effects among Fukushima Prefecture residents have been documented that are directly attributable to radiation exposure from the FDNPS accident
-
- 7
U.S. Geological Survey, 2020. Cesium, in Mineral Commodity Summaries 2020 .
The last table of reserves by country (2019), the Sinclair mine, the sale of Tanco, the FDA notice on cesium chloride and the 2019 irradiator leak.
-
In May 2019, a blood irradiator that used cesium-137 spilled while being moved from a medical research center to a secure disposal site.
-
compounded cesium chloride, which had been used as an alternative cancer treatment
-
- 8
U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 2020. Public Health Alert Concerning Dietary Supplements Containing Cesium Salts .
Heart and other risks of cesium chloride and other cesium salts taken as supplements; the warning of July 2018 on compounded drugs. Read with Firecrawl.
-
in July 2018, the FDA warned health care professionals that cesium salts presented a significant safety risk in compounding drugs
-
The FDA is warning consumers to avoid using dietary supplements containing cesium chloride or any other cesium salt
-
potentially fatal cardiac arrhythmias, hypokalemia (low potassium), seizures, syncope (fainting, unresponsiveness), and death
-
- 9
U.S. Geological Survey (W.C. Butterman, W.E. Brooks and R.G. Reese Jr.), 2005. Mineral Commodity Profiles: Cesium (Open-File Report 2004-1432) .
History, minerals, refining methods, uses, substitutes, reserves of 2003, world use, and producer prices from 1962 to 1991.
-
The mining and processing of cesium minerals are on such a small scale that environmental hazards or damage caused by the production of cesium are minimal.
-