The cobalt in the beer
In 1965 and 1966, 48 heavy beer drinkers in Quebec City went to hospital with a sudden heart disease, and 20 died. Their doctors traced it to a cobalt salt that brewers added to keep the foam on the beer.
In August 1965, four patients were admitted to hospitals in Quebec City with failing hearts. One more came in September and eight in October. They went to eight different hospitals, under different physicians, and for months nobody counted them together (Editorial 1967).
By April 1966 there were 48 patients, and 20 of them were dead (Morin and others 1967). All 48 drank large amounts of beer, and 46 of them drank the same draught beer. The cause that their doctors gave, a year and a half later, was a salt of cobalt that the brewery added to keep the foam on the beer.
Forty-eight patients
Most of the patients lived in the Lower Town of Quebec City. Forty-four of the 48 drank more than 100 ounces of beer a day, which is about 3 liters, and 30 drank more than 200 ounces. Forty-five had done so for 10 years or more. There were 46 men and two women. Eighteen of the men and both women died, the first in October 1965 and the last in April 1966 (Morin and others 1967).
Three physicians, Yves Morin, André Tétu and Gaston Mercier, had most of the patients in their care. Some patients had symptoms for one day before they came to hospital, and few had them for more than a month. The writer of the journal’s editorial knew of no mild cases and called it “an ‘all or none’ disease” (Editorial 1967).
According to the editorial, other drinkers had the same beer, in the same amounts and for as many years, ate the same food, and stayed well.
The search
In March 1966 the newspapers reported the deaths. The editorial of 1967 called these reports “exaggerated” and quoted a figure of “hundreds of deaths”. That month Jacques Gélinas, the Deputy Minister of Health of Quebec, set up a committee: forensic doctors, epidemiologists, pathologists, members of the federal Food and Drug Directorate, a researcher from a brewery and members of the provincial police (Morin and others 1967; Editorial 1967).
The committee found no virus, and then looked for arsenic. In 1900 about 2,000 beer drinkers in Manchester, England, fell ill, and a Royal Commission found arsenic in the beer. A test for arsenic needs clippings of hair and nails, and the men who had to give them, in the words of the editorial, “spent all their days in various taverns, their nights anywhere and everywhere—they had no fixed addresses. Nevertheless, this was done; no arsenic was found!”
The committee also looked for pesticides, ergot alkaloids, papain, bromine and a list of metals from magnesium to radium, and found none of them.
The beer that Dow destroyed
In their papers of 1967 the doctors called the beer “brand XXX”. In August 1966 Gerald Taaffe wrote in Maclean’s magazine that it was Dow, brewed in Quebec City (Taaffe 1966). According to Taaffe, Dow had half of the beer market of metropolitan Quebec, and 70% in some areas.
Taaffe spoke to Dow’s officers. On 21 March 1966, in his account, the coroner, Paul des Ruisseaux, told Dow that there were 39 cases and 14 dead. The police had looked at 32 of the cases, and all but one were Dow drinkers. Dow said that the doctors and the health authorities did not contact the brewery in the first months. One of its officers asked Taaffe, “why didn’t they call us?”
On the evening of 29 March, Dow’s president, Pierre Gendron, asked Gélinas if it would help the investigation to take the Quebec City beer off the market. Gélinas said that it would. The next morning the bottling line of the brewery ran backward. Machines turned the full bottles upside down, trucks brought back beer from all of eastern Quebec, and the 8,000-gallon vats were emptied into the drain. “We had to do it slowly,” a Dow executive told Taaffe, “we couldn’t have the sewers foaming up.”
In almost four weeks Dow destroyed nearly a million gallons of beer, about 4.5 million liters if these were Canadian gallons, at a cost of about $625,000. A Maclean’s text of 2008 says that Dow “dumped all its vats into the St. Lawrence” (Patriquin 2008). Taaffe, in 1966, wrote of the drain and the sewers and did not mention the river.
When Taaffe’s article came out, the committee had found nothing in Dow beer that could explain the deaths. Cobalt was discussed at a meeting of the investigators at Laval University in May 1966, but Taaffe reported that the cobalt in the beer was “below the legally permissible limit, and far below the levels normally accepted as toxic”. Dow started to brew in Quebec City again on 27 June 1966, without cobalt. A Dow official said the reason was that cobalt was mentioned at the meeting, and that the brewers did not think it was dangerous.
The doctors’ conclusion
The doctors published their conclusion on 7 October 1967, in an issue of the Canadian Medical Association Journal that was almost all about the 48 patients.
According to the editorial, the doctors first suspected cobalt when the pathologists saw, in the thyroid glands taken at autopsy, changes like the ones that cobalt causes. Morin and his colleague Philippe Daniel wrote that they looked at what was in the beer because of the Manchester poisoning (Morin and Daniel 1967).
Some Canadian brewers added cobalt sulfate to beer from July 1965, to make the foam last. According to Morin and Daniel, taverns now washed their glasses with detergent and did not rinse them well, and the detergent left on the glass broke the foam. Large breweries added cobalt only to draught beer. The Quebec City brewery was small and made one batch for bottles and barrels, so all its beer had cobalt.
A beer of the same name was brewed in Montreal, with cobalt in the draught beer, and Montreal had no cases. The editorial gave 0.075 parts of cobalt per million for the Montreal beer and 1.2 parts per million for the Quebec City beer, which is 16 times more.
In Quebec City the first patients came one month after the brewery started to add cobalt, and no new patients came after one month without it. In Omaha, Nebraska, doctors had seen the same disease from June 1964: 64 patients in two years, and about half of them died. One of the beers sold there contained cobalt. Morin and some colleagues flew to Omaha, and the last patient there fell ill within a month after the cobalt was taken out. A third group of patients was reported in Leuven, Belgium.
Morin and Daniel wrote that they could not get the cobalt content of North American beers “from government sources or from the industry”.
The dose
Doctors of that time gave cobalt as a medicine for anemia. Morin and Daniel calculated that 24 pints of the beer held about 8 mg of cobalt sulfate, and that a patient on the usual tablets took 60 mg of cobalt chloride a day. In Manchester in 1900, doctors gave epileptic patients ten times more arsenic than the beer drinkers took, for long periods.
The doctors’ 8 mg and the editorial’s 1.2 parts per million are different amounts. At 1.2 parts per million, 24 imperial pints (13.6 liters) hold about 16 mg of cobalt, and 8 mg of cobalt sulfate holds 3 mg of cobalt at most. We did not find the measurement behind either number.
In February and March 1967 the doctors saw 22 of the survivors again. Sixteen had gone back to the same beer, in the same amounts, and none had signs of heart disease. From this, Morin and Daniel concluded that alcohol “was not the sole etiological agent”. The writer of the editorial added that nobody could explain why some heavy drinkers fell ill and others, with the same beer, did not. Heavy drinkers who worked in the breweries were not affected, in Quebec or in Omaha.
Morin and Daniel called the disease “multicausal”. They wrote that alcohol and a poor diet probably “played an important part”, and that cobalt “was the essential factor”. In animals, the drug EDTA prevents cobalt poisoning. If the doctors had known that cobalt was in the beer, they wrote, EDTA “might have saved some of our patients”.
The rule in the United States
On 25 October 1963 the Food and Drug Administration allowed brewers to add cobalt salts to beer, up to 1.2 parts of cobalt per million, “to improve foam stability and to prevent gushing”. One company, J. E. Siebel Sons’ of Chicago, asked for the rule, and the agency printed it in the Federal Register (Federal Register 1963). The limit is the same number that the editorial gave for the Quebec City beer.
On 31 August 1965, in the month of the first patients in Quebec City, the agency raised the limit to 1.5 parts per million. The same company asked for it (Federal Register 1965).
On 30 June 1966 the agency proposed to end the rule. It wrote that “questions have been raised concerning the safety of the compounds” and that brewers were reported to have stopped using them. Nobody sent a comment, and the rule ended on 12 August 1966 (Federal Register 1966).
Today, a food in the United States with any added cobalt salt is “deemed to be adulterated” (21 CFR 189.120). We did not find the Canadian rule of 1965, or the date when Canada ended it.
Sources
- Morin, Y. L., Foley, A. R., Martineau, G. and Roussel, J. (1967). Quebec beer-drinkers’ cardiomyopathy: forty-eight cases. Canadian Medical Association Journal 97(15), 881–883. PubMed Central
- Morin, Y. and Daniel, P. (1967). Quebec beer-drinkers’ cardiomyopathy: etiological considerations. Canadian Medical Association Journal 97(15), 926–928. PubMed Central
- Editorial (1967). The mystery of the Quebec beer-drinkers’ cardiomyopathy. Canadian Medical Association Journal 97(15), 930–931. No author given. PubMed Central
- Taaffe, G. (1966). The great beer scare. Maclean’s, 20 August 1966. Internet Archive copy of the Maclean’s archive
- Patriquin, M. (2008). Of meat, beer, disease and death. Maclean’s website, 26 August 2008. macleans.ca
- Federal Register (1963). Food additives: cobaltous salts. 25 October 1963, volume 28, page 11454. govinfo.gov, full issue
- Federal Register (1965). Food additives: cobaltous salts. 31 August 1965, volume 30, page 11171. govinfo.gov, full issue
- Federal Register (1966). Cobaltous salts: the proposal of 30 June 1966, volume 31, page 9008, and the order of 12 August 1966, volume 31, page 10744. govinfo.gov, issue of 30 June; issue of 12 August
- Code of Federal Regulations, title 21, section 189.120, Cobaltous salts and its derivatives. eCFR